HawkoReview
Waller

Waller on a Hawkish Fed: December Hike, 50 Basis Points Possible

Governor Waller said he would back a 25 basis point hike in December and could consider 50 if October CPI runs hot. A hawkish Fed speech, reviewed in detail.

Nov 10, 20264 min read
Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board building in Washington
Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board building in Washington. Image: Ohio Redevelopment Projects - ODSA via wikimedia (CC BY 2.0)

The news

Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller said on November 10 that further tightening will be needed “sooner rather than later” and that, even if October inflation improves, he would still support a 25 basis point increase in the policy rate at the Federal Open Market Committee’s December meeting. Speaking at the Bank of England Watchers Conference in London, he added that if October consumer price data resemble the past two monthly readings, with core CPI around 0.3 percent or higher, a 50 basis point hike should be considered. Hiking only 25 basis points in that case, he said, would put the Committee’s credibility at risk.

Waller explained his vote to hold at the most recent meeting. The FOMC kept the target range at 3-3/4 to 4 percent on October 28 by a 10-2 vote. Waller said he supported the majority because the Committee’s communication about likely tightening had already led markets to price in some of it. What matters, he argued, is that promised hikes are eventually carried out, and it is not necessary to raise rates at consecutive meetings. If markets conclude the hikes will not come, expectations fall and policy loosens in an undesirable way.

On the economy, he described strong growth and a stable labor market. Real GDP rose 3.4 percent in the third quarter on the initial estimate, supported by consumer spending and business investment in high-tech equipment tied to the AI buildout. The unemployment rate was 4.1 percent in October, payrolls rose 165,000, and the 6-month and 12-month average gains are closer to 80,000 a month, a bit above most estimates of the breakeven pace.

Inflation is the focus. September PCE prices rose 0.5 percent on the month and 3.7 percent over twelve months, and core PCE rose 0.3 percent and 3.1 percent. More than 70 percent of core PCE service components showed 12-month increases above 3 percent. He said the breadth of the increases concerns him, with core goods and core market-based services excluding housing both elevated. Staff research suggests AI-related and energy price pressures may not fade soon, and he cited Strait of Hormuz insurance and ship-to-ship oil transfers as adding $20 to $30 a barrel to oil prices, according to reports.

Our analysis

The speech is a clear example of a hawkish Fed argument built in two layers. The first is about sequencing: Waller defends a pause in October as consistent with a tightening bias, which tells markets that a hold is not a change of course. The second is about size, where he opens the door to 50 basis points and ties it to a specific data trigger, the October CPI release scheduled for later that day.

Two members of the Committee, Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack, preferred a quarter-point increase in October. Waller’s remarks put him on the side of tightening in December while keeping the option of a larger move conditional. That conditionality gives the Committee room to respond to data without committing in advance.

The speech’s second half is a set of questions about labor market dynamism rather than a policy signal. Waller asks whether a stable labor market is necessarily a healthy one, noting that hiring and firing rates are both low. He cites aging, rising educational attainment and elevated uncertainty from AI, tariffs and immigration policy as possible causes. He says the share of unemployed workers out for 27 weeks or more, on a three-month average, has risen from around 18 percent at the end of 2022 to more than 27 percent through September 2026, which he reads as a sign that the labor market is not as healthy as the unemployment rate suggests. He says he does not have answers and sees the questions as worth more research.

Room for disagreement

Waller says he sees little disagreement about the basics of the outlook, but there is disagreement about timing. Two colleagues wanted to move in October. Others may argue that a labor market with low hiring and rising long-term unemployment argues for patience, and the speech itself acknowledges the possibility that lower dynamism could be a drag on productivity growth. He also notes that some of the earlier inflation pressure came from non-market prices he discounts, which suggests the current breadth of price increases is the more reliable signal. Waller stresses that the views are his own and not necessarily those of colleagues.

What to watch

  • The October CPI release, which Waller named as the test: core around 0.3 percent or more would, in his words, bring 50 basis points into consideration.
  • Whether other FOMC participants echo the 25 basis point December view or the larger option.
  • The December SEP and dot plot, which will show how many participants project further hikes.
  • Fed staff research on energy pass-through, which Waller said suggests pressure could persist well into 2027.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related